What Former No. 1 Fleets Are Up to Today
This year's Elite Fleets — former No. 1 operations — continue to lead the industry with new initiatives.


When an operation takes home the No. 1 Leading Fleet award, its story do not end there. The leaders of these organizations are often asked to judge awards, including the Leading Fleets award, and former No. 1 operations that continue to perform at a high level are recognized as Elite Fleets.
This year, five high-performing operations were recognized during the Honors Celebration at the Government Fleet Expo & Conference (GFX) as Elite Fleets: the City of Culver City, Calif.; City of Mesa, Ariz.; City of Boise, Idaho; City of Columbus, Ohio; and San Bernardino County, Calif. Since taking the No. 1 spot, each of these fleets has continued to improve their operation and set an example of innovation for fellow fleet managers.
We caught up with this year’s Elite Fleets to learn more about how they continue to improve their operations.
City of Culver City, Calif. • No. 1 in 2013
Led by Paul Condran, fleet services manager, and Allison Choen, management analyst

Key Stats:
Fleet size: 637
Staff size: 50
Operating budget: $9M
Facilities: 2
Fueling sites: 3
Initiatives: Culver City is reviewing the application of battery-electric transit buses and front-loader refuse trucks. In June the fleet transitioned to 100% renewable natural gas and began selling low-carbon fuel credits through the State of California’s cap & trade programs. The city is also upgrading its bus system to incorporate AVL/GPS and alert users of real-time arrivals via smartphone.
Shows leadership byparticipating in industry discussions about the transition to new technology, such as autonomous vehicles and drive-by-wire solutions.
City of Mesa, Ariz. • No. 1 in 2014
Led by Pete Scarafiotti, CAFM, CEM, CPFP, fleet director & automotive engineer

Key Stats:
Fleet size: 2,000
Staff size: 90
Operating budget: $18M
Facilities: 3
Fueling sites: 7, dispensing gasoline, biodiesel, and CNG
Miles traveled annually: 1.5 million
Initiatives: For the first time in more than 40 years, the fleet brought motorcycle maintenance in house. In addition, the fleet continues to expand its parts consignment program to include more vendors, expand its contract retention program so vendors concentrate on satisfying contracts as soon as possible, and expand its warranty reimbursement program which brings in more than $500,000 in refunds annually.
Shows leadership by earning certifications and recognition across the industry from organizations such as the National Institute for Automotive Service Excellence (ASE), Coalition for Green Fleet Management, and Government Fleet Management Alliance.
City of Boise, Idaho • No. 1 in 2015
Led by Craig Croner, CPFP, administrative services manager

Key Stats:
Fleet size: 1,544
Staff size: 17.5
Miles traveled annually: 4.6 million
Facilites: 3
Fuel dispensed annually: 491,000 gallons of unleaded, diesel, propane autogas, and E-85
Initiatives: The city is transitioning to a web-based fleet software that is scheduled to go live in August. The fleet is also expanding its use of fuel management software from six to nine fuel sites. In addition, the fleet has continued to replace older gas-powered vehicles in its motor pool with hybrid and battery-electric vehicles.
Shows leadership by collaborating with the Idaho Regional Fleet Group, which has expanded to 11 agencies. This year, the group created a cooperative purchasing agreement, continued its monthly meetings, and hosted regional training seminars. The city also hosted several regional fleet maintenance training seminars, attended by more than 50 participants from cities, counties, and states surrounding Idaho.
City of Columbus, Ohio • No. 1 in 2016
Led by Kelly Reagan, fleet administrator

Key Stats:
Fleet size: 6,400
Staff size: 138
Operating budget: $38 million
Facilities: 4
Miles traveled annually: 24 million
Work orders processed annually: 21,700
Labor hours billed annually: 160,000
Initiatives: The city continues to implement its Smart City program, recently purchasing 93 electric vehicles and getting ready to purchase another 107 over the next 18 months. In July, the fleet opened a new fueling site with compressed natural gas, diesel, propane autogas, and unleaded fuel. With this addition, the city can close older fueling sites and further centralize its fueling operation.
Shows leadership by becoming an ASE testing facility. The city can now host exams for its fleet team as well as Municipal Equipment Maintenance Association (MEMA) Ohio chapter members. The city also insources motorcycle repairs, CNG operation & maintenance, and CNG fueling for neighboring entities.
San Bernardino County, Calif. • No. 1 in 2017
Led by Ron Lindsey, CAFS, director of fleet management

Key Stats:
Fleet size: 6,000
Staff size: 97
Departments served: 52
Fuel sites: 61
Fuel dispensed annually: 2.8 million gallons of unleaded and diesel
Miles traveled annually: 17.2 million
Initiatives: San Bernardino County has begun construction on a 24,000-sq.-ft. service center, is installing automated fuel tank monitoring at all fuel sites, is expanding insourcing beyond the $1 million revenue already brought in annually, and added environmentally friendly car washes to multiple sites.
Shows leadership as a member of NAFA and MEMA, assisting with recruitment and interview panels. San Bernardino County has hosted fleets interested in viewing the county’s motor pool and parts operations, and has assisted other fleets in developing replacement parameters.
More Operations

What Can Disappear After a Fleet Crash?
This week, we look at drone footage, what fleets should document before repairs begin, and share a quick poll.

Does Your Government Fleet Handle Refuse and Waste Operations? Take Our Poll
Government Fleet wants to hear from public-sector fleet professionals about their responsibilities for refuse collection and waste management equipment.

Fleet Replacement Decisions, Waste Fleet Technology and the GFX Deadline
Is your next vehicle the right fit, can your records settle a missed pickup dispute, and what could your fleet teach others at GFX 2027?

Is Delaying Fleet Replacement Really Saving Money?
Could delaying replacement cost your fleet more than it saves? This week’s recap takes a closer look, plus an update on GFX 2027.
What Government Fleets Are Missing About Their True Costs
What are fleet budgets missing, and how can agencies use the data they already collect to make a stronger case for change?

Rethinking Fleet Decisions From the Budget Office to the Shop
This October we looked back at how public fleets are reconsidering familiar processes and using what they learn to make better decisions.

Who Owns the Message on a Refuse Truck?
Refuse trucks can carry public messages into neighborhoods, but keeping those messages current takes planning and clear responsibility.

Who Deserves Fleet Recognition and What Could You Teach at GFX?
Who helped shape your fleet career, and what have you learned that could help someone else?

What’s Haunting Public Sector Fleets?
Public sector fleet challenges rarely happen in isolation, and addressing one often means understanding how it connects to another.

Is Keeping Older Fleet Vehicles Really Saving Money?
Is keeping vehicles longer saving money, and what happens when a diagnostic test points to the wrong fix?

