GF Blue logo
MenuMENU
SearchSEARCH

State of Pennsylvania Keeps Poor Track of State Vehicles, Audit Finds

HARRISBURG, PA - Gov. Ed G. Rendell's administration is doing a poor job of tracking which of its employees are assigned state vehicles and why, and whether those vehicles are being used and maintained properly.

by Staff
February 9, 2009
3 min to read


HARRISBURG, PA - Gov. Ed G. Rendell's administration is doing a poor job of tracking which of its employees are assigned state vehicles and why, and whether those vehicles are being used and maintained properly, according to the Philadelphia Inquirer.

Those findings were contained in a recent report issued by Auditor General Jack Wagner's office. The audit faults the Department of General Services, responsible for managing the state's fleet of 16,000-plus cars, for "weak leadership, incomplete record-keeping, and little accountability in how cars are being assigned."

Ad Loading...

"With the commonwealth facing a multibillion-dollar budget deficit, the Department of General Services must seize the wheel and take control of Pennsylvania's vehicle fleet to save taxpayer dollars and ensure the public that the privilege of operating a state vehicle is not being abused," the report states.

The total cost of acquiring, maintaining, insuring and fueling the state's fleet is $72.5 million a year, according to the Philadelphia Inquirer.

A big part of the problem, according to the audit, is that until recently, the department had a "decentralized" approach to managing its fleet: It allowed agencies, commissions and boards to set their own policies on which employees received cars and how they were expected to maintain them.

The result, according to the audit, was that the department could not provide complete and up-to-date records to answer basic questions, including which employees drove state-owned cars, what their job titles were, and how many miles they drove.

In a recent interview, Department of General Services Secretary James P. Creedon said few of the audit's findings came as a surprise.

Ad Loading...

He said the administration inherited the decentralized system that Wagner's audit describes, and that he and others had been working for several years to revamp it.

Creedon also said his department has made many of the recommended changes, including consolidating staffing and procurement. 

Beyond that, the secretary said, the department has worked on downsizing the state's fleet, reducing gas consumption, and increasing the number of hybrid vehicles.

"It's going to take some time for all these changes to kick in, but you will see the results," Creedon said.

Senate President Pro Tempore Joe Scarnati (R., Jefferson) called Wagner's audit "jaw-dropping" and said it indicated that General Services "was unable to ensure the responsible use of taxpayer money."

Ad Loading...

Scarnati's caucus is pushing a package of bills, including one that would place more restrictions on the use of state cars. Wagner's office recommended that the department develop a form that every agency must complete for anyone requesting permanent assignment of a state vehicle. That form should contain the employee's name, job title, and purpose for requesting the vehicle.

Wagner's office is also recommending that the department approve any permanent assignment of a car to a state employee and develop a toll-free number, as well as a form on its Web site that would allow citizens to report suspected abuse of a state vehicle.

More Operations

Two buses with a logo above them.
Operations•by News/Media Release•October 5, 2026

ENC Unveils its ZAVIR Medium-Duty Shuttle

Two variants of the concept shuttles were revealed: a low-floor configuration and a high-floor configuration.

Read More →
A graphic of an auto shop and cheat sheet text.
Operations•October 2, 2026

Could Your Next Fleet Technician Start as an Intern?

What if your next technician hasn’t worked in a fleet shop yet? What fleets are doing to free up time.

Read More →
a technician working with a text overlay that says Building Talent From Within
Operations•by Jeanny Abraham•October 2, 2026

How Phoenix Is Building Its Next Generation of Fleet Technicians

With more than 8,000 vehicles and pieces of equipment to maintain, the City of Phoenix could not afford to wait for fully trained technicians to walk through the door. Instead, they revamped their entire workforce strategy and showed how public fleets can create their own talent pipeline while preparing existing employees for increasingly complex vehicles.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
A youtube graphic with a collage fleet images.
Operations•October 2, 2026

What’s Slowing Your Fleet Down?

Could a change in how work gets done help your fleet return vehicles to service sooner?

Read More →
A story graphic with data and cars.
Operations•by Nichole Osinski•October 1, 2026

Can Public Fleets Trust the Data Driving Their Decisions?

Public fleets have more data than ever, but inconsistent records and missing information can still undermine maintenance, replacement, and cost decisions.

Read More →
John Deere 40 P-Tier Compact Excavator
Operations•September 28, 2026

John Deere Introduces 40 P-Tier Compact Excavator

John Deere is adding a compact excavator designed for crews that need to move equipment between jobsites and handle multiple types of work with one machine. The 40 P-Tier weighs less than 10,000 pounds and offers configurable hydraulics, attachment options, and connected fleet-management capabilities.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
A cheat sheet thumbnail with images of a checklist and fleet image.
Operations•September 25, 2026

How Leading Fleets Improve and Why Business Plans Matter

This week, we look at what past Leading Fleet winners can teach us about making progress, plus how to build a business plan your fleet will actually use.

Read More →
hall of fame logo with award
Operations•by Staff Writer•September 25, 2026

Nominate a Fleet Leader for the 2027 Public Fleet Hall of Fame

Do you know a fleet leader who has made a lasting impact on the industry? Nominate this fleet professional for the 2027 Public Fleet Hall of Fame.

Read More →
A youtube graphic with fleet images.
Operations•September 23, 2026

Why Fleet Business Plans Need Three Perspectives

A fleet business plan should help agency leaders understand the fleet’s value, give the organization a clear direction, and establish shared expectations with customer departments.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
A graphic with a checklist and cars.
Operations•September 18, 2026

How Oil Analysis, Safety Technology, and Fleet Awards Drive Improvement

What happens when fleets let measured results guide their next decision?

Read More →