Related: New York City Seeks More Diversity from Truck Vendors
NYC to Pay $1.3M in Racial Bias Lawsuit
The New York City Department of Transportation has agreed to pay $1.3 million to 14 employees to resolve a lawsuit alleging a pattern of racial discrimination within its Fleet Services unit.

Photo via Flickr/Karen Neoh

Photo via Flickr/Karen Neoh
The New York City Department of Transportation (NYCDOT) has agreed to pay $1.3 million to employees to resolve a lawsuit alleging a pattern of racial discrimination and retaliation within its Fleet Services unit from at least October 2007 through May 2016. The U.S. Attorney for the Southern District of New York announced the consent decree on June 15.
The city offered monetary compensation to 14 individuals, including mechanics and a blacksmith, for back pay and compensatory damages ranging from $60,000 to $168,000. The city will also pay the complainant who brought this case to the attention of the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission $150,000 in compensatory damages and attorney’s fees. In addition, the city will also offer the complainant and two other minority candidates, all of whom were promoted by the city after the U.S. Attorney’s Office informed the city of its investigation, retroactive seniority benefits commensurate with having been promoted during the time period relevant to the complaint.
The complaint alleges that as of October 2007, the executive director of Fleet Services routinely and openly used racial epithets to describe African American employees. Upon an investigation that found the complaint true, that executive director retired and was replaced by his second-in-command, who had been complicit in the discrimination. Beginning in 2010, and throughout his tenure, the second executive director routinely and systematically excluded minorities from preferred assignments and special projects, exclusively choosing white candidates for the assignments that would provide the best opportunity for further advancement within Fleet Services.
Individuals who spoke out against the discriminatory practices were subjected to retaliatory conduct and threats by the second executive director, and several other members of Fleet Services’ executive leadership who witnessed one such threat failed to take any action.
As part of the consent decree, NYCDOT made several admissions, including that the executive directors used racial epithets to describe African Americans and took personnel actions motivated by race. The consent decree also requires the city to take steps to ensure that it complies with Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 in its future promotional selection processes.
Fleet Services is a unit within NYCDOT that employs approximately 200 individuals in a range of trades, such as machinists, auto mechanics, electricians, blacksmiths, and engineers.
More Operations

Emergency Response, Fleet Sales and New Technology
This week’s fleet news covers emergency preparedness, shifting vehicle sales, electric truck investments, and new tools for monitoring road conditions.
Read More →
NCDOT Adds Dash Cam Imagery to Statewide Traffic Monitoring
North Carolina transportation officials are adding another set of eyes to roads that aren't covered by fixed traffic cameras. A statewide deployment gives NCDOT access to on-vehicle imagery to verify conditions during work zones, severe weather, emergencies, and other traffic events.
Read More →
Turning a Bottleneck Into a Blueprint: How Tallahassee Rethought Police Fleet Readiness
For Tallahassee, finally receiving 87 delayed police cruisers created a new problem: how to get them on the road without creating a massive backlog. The solution would change more than the upfit process.
Read More →
AI, Police Fleet Readiness and Fire Apparatus News
See how AI, a reworked police-vehicle upfitting process, and a fire apparatus acquisition could affect public fleet operations.
Read More →
Stay ready, set and safer with verified fleet inspections.
When fleet inspections aren’t verifiable, missed defects can quickly become downtime, safety risks, and service delays. This white paper shows government and municipal fleet leaders how digital inspections can improve accountability, catch issues earlier, and keep vehicles ready when they’re needed most.
Read More →
How AI and Automation Work Together to Reduce Government Fleet Downtime
As their assets age and their budgets’ purchasing power shrinks, government fleet managers are facing growing pressure to do more with less.
Read More →
Police Fleet Innovation, EV Strategy and AI
See how public fleets are rethinking police vehicle readiness, electrification, workplace culture, and driver workflows.
Read More →
From What He Inherited to What He’ll Leave Behind: David Renschler’s Lessons in Leadership
David Renschler walked into Fairfield with plenty to learn and no idea what awaited him. Twenty years later, the lessons from what came next are still shaping his approach to fleet.
Read More →
Have Fleets Changed Enough to Solve the Technician Shortage?
Are government fleets finally closing the gap on the technician shortage, or are critical challenges still holding them back?
Read More →
How Public Fleets Are Rethinking Vehicles, EVs, and Culture
From mission-specific vehicles to EV planning and culture change, this week’s stories show how public fleets are rethinking the way they operate.
Read More →

