New Study Says Salt Lake County Received Top Deals on Cars with One-Year Rotation
SALT LAKE COUNTY, UT – Scrapping some of Salt Lake County's Rapid Rotation Program in the fleet division may not save taxpayers money after all, according to a report by the Salt Lake Tribune.
SALT LAKE COUNTY, UT – Scrapping some of Salt Lake County's Rapid Rotation Program in the fleet division may not save taxpayers money after all, according to a report by the Salt Lake Tribune. Instead, according to the county's own fiscal analysts, it could cost $8,000 per year per cruiser on Sheriff's Office cars alone. Translation: a million-dollar annual hit to taxpayers. Under the current system, a sheriff's Ford Crown Victoria can be purchased and fully equipped for $24,500. If sold just one year later, the county can get $20,500. But wait two years, the value plummets to $12,500. And after four years, the police cruisers nab less than $4,000 at auction houses, said Darrin Casper, county council fiscal analyst. Paul Lauria, a fleet consultant with Maryland-based Mercury Associates, says the recommendation to shift the rotation to three or four years is still in draft form. But he stands by the findings. In the meantime, the county's analysis mirrors the message of former fleet manager Nick Morgan, who was fired in June. He says he showed the same numbers to public works officials, "but no one seemed to believe us. It validates what we've been doing all along. The program works. It always has worked. It's too bad it's been so damaged and people have maligned it so much." Public Works Director John Patterson has said proposed changes to the fleet's operations would save taxpayers millions over the next decade. Since then, officials from public works and the mayor's office frequently flagged rapid rotation as the next program to be cut. The fleet division has been folded into a newly created administrative services department. But a resolution on how often to rotate has been sluggish – presumably because of the consultant's research, reported the Salt Lake Tribune. Doug Willmore, the county's chief administrative officer calls the disparity between the two recommendations "a local aberration" since Salt Lake County is the only entity that swaps out police cruisers after a year. Sheriff Aaron Kennard says the suggestion to keep vehicles longer simply "doesn't make sense. No one wants to buy a 3- or 4-year old patrol car," he said. Fiscal analyst Casper says selling the cruisers before they depreciate will keep the fleet in the black and provide other cities with top-notch cars. "It creates a win-win situation." Even Salt Lake County Mayor Peter Corroon hinted the county may decide to trash that part of the study. "We're going to tweak their numbers to a more-localized result," said the mayor, according to the Salt Lake Tribune.
More Operations

Who Deserves Fleet Recognition and What Could You Teach at GFX?
Who helped shape your fleet career, and what have you learned that could help someone else?
Read More →
What’s Haunting Public Sector Fleets?
Public sector fleet challenges rarely happen in isolation, and addressing one often means understanding how it connects to another.
Read More →
Is Keeping Older Fleet Vehicles Really Saving Money?
Is keeping vehicles longer saving money, and what happens when a diagnostic test points to the wrong fix?
Read More →
How Smart Fleet Strategy Can Help Local Government Agencies Do More with Less
Keeping a vehicle longer may ease this year’s budget, but what does it cost the next one? A closer look at fleet decisions can reveal opportunities to reduce spending while protecting essential services.
Read More →
Connect with Government Fleet on LinkedIn
From industry news and fleet management strategies to conversations with peers, Government Fleet's LinkedIn page offers public-sector fleet professionals another way to stay informed and connected.
Read More →
Town of Queen Creek Named Most Successful Fleet Award Winner of Inaugural RTA Fleet Success Awards
Five fleets were honored at RTA Connect 2026 in Chicago for excellence across resource efficiency, intentional culture, risk management, and stakeholder satisfaction.
Read More →
A buyer's guide to fleet management software in 2027
Buying fleet management software in 2027 means looking beyond features and price. As fleet operations, technology and expectations evolve, this guide explores what today’s fleet professionals should consider when choosing a system that can deliver value now and adapt to what comes next.
Read More →
Hazard Alerts, Fleet Car Sales Rise and a New Shuttle Concept
Fleet car sales doubled, but the bigger picture tells a different story in this week’s roundup.
Read More →
How St. Johns County Turned Fleet Data Into Better Replacement Decisions
St. Johns County, Florida, had fleet data, but turning it into reliable decision guidance was another matter. Instead of starting over with a new fleet management system, the county connected existing tools and built a scoring system that gives managers an objective look at fleet health.
Read More →
Fleet Forward Conference Introduces One-Day Passes for 2026
New one-day registration lets fleet professionals attend Tuesday, Wednesday, or Thursday, with passes available for $249.
Read More →

