GFX 2013: How to Implement a Take-Home Vehicle Policy
At the 2013 Government Fleet Expo, John Webster of Salt Lake County, UT, and other attendees, went over real-world examples of how to implement a policy for take-home vehicles. What's your criteria?

Audience members shared their own experiences, in what became a discussion on the challenges faced when implementing a policy. William Griffiths, division chief, Fleet Management Services in Montgomery County, Md., suggested that mileage logs should be required to help enforce take-home policies.

Audience members shared their own experiences, in what became a discussion on the challenges faced when implementing a policy. William Griffiths, division chief, Fleet Management Services in Montgomery County, Md., suggested that mileage logs should be required to help enforce take-home policies.
Many counties and public fleets allow employees to take vehicles home. But what does this option cost a fleet, and how do you ensure that this option doesn't get abused? At the 2013 Government Fleet Expo, John Webster, CPFP, Salt Lake County, Utah, went over what he has learned in implementing a policy on take-home vehicles, and how fleets can do the same.
Webster first explained that you should set a criteria on what situations consitute a vehicle to be taken home. This criteria should include how many miles out a vehicle can go, though he said the best practice is keeping vehicles within the county line. He said that fleet managers must ask themselves why they allow take-homes.
"Policymakers can change policy; it's hard to police them, so you have to have a set criteria for yourself," Webster said.
In order to prevent too many personal requests from changing your proposal, it's important to have every piece of data and analysis on why you've selected that criteria. "Make sure those policymakers are made aware on what the cost is to allow these take-home vehicles," Webster said.

John Webster, CPFP, Salt Lake County, Utah, discussed why it's important for a fleet to have set criteria on when take-home vehicles should be allowed.
In the case of Salt Lake County, Webster explained that when he first proposed a policy, it went to a steering committee four times before it was voted on by the county board. Because of personal requests, "it gets watered down," he said.
He admitted that this can be difficult since oftentimes it's the policymakers who have their own requests that deviate from the proposed criteria.
But, if you have a cost-analysis prepared for every department, then it's easier for them to see why a policy is necessary for take-home vehicles. "A cost-analysis is one of the biggest ways to influence a decision," Webster said.
This is also why he suggests that every employee looking to take a vehicle home should have to fill out a form — essentially an application — and that these requests should be required to fill out or reviewed annually. This form, he said, helps enforce the policy.
In reviewing forms in addition to creating a policy, Webster said that a steering committee — if not already available — should be created, or a fleet board. "However you want to route it," he said.
Audience members also made their own suggestions on how to enforce the policy once it's created. One suggestion, for example, was to require a mileage log and/or use telematics to track vehicle use.
More Operations

Hazard Alerts, Fleet Car Sales Rise and a New Shuttle Concept
Fleet car sales doubled, but the bigger picture tells a different story in this week’s roundup.
Read More →
How St. Johns County Turned Fleet Data Into Better Replacement Decisions
St. Johns County, Florida, had fleet data, but turning it into reliable decision guidance was another matter. Instead of starting over with a new fleet management system, the county connected existing tools and built a scoring system that gives managers an objective look at fleet health.
Read More →
Fleet Forward Conference Introduces One-Day Passes for 2026
New one-day registration lets fleet professionals attend Tuesday, Wednesday, or Thursday, with passes available for $249.
Read More →
ENC Unveils its ZAVIR Medium-Duty Shuttle
Two variants of the concept shuttles were revealed: a low-floor configuration and a high-floor configuration.
Read More →
Could Your Next Fleet Technician Start as an Intern?
What if your next technician hasn’t worked in a fleet shop yet? What fleets are doing to free up time.
Read More →
How Phoenix Is Building Its Next Generation of Fleet Technicians
With more than 8,000 vehicles and pieces of equipment to maintain, the City of Phoenix could not afford to wait for fully trained technicians to walk through the door. Instead, they revamped their entire workforce strategy and showed how public fleets can create their own talent pipeline while preparing existing employees for increasingly complex vehicles.
Read More →
What’s Slowing Your Fleet Down?
Could a change in how work gets done help your fleet return vehicles to service sooner?
Read More →
Can Public Fleets Trust the Data Driving Their Decisions?
Public fleets have more data than ever, but inconsistent records and missing information can still undermine maintenance, replacement, and cost decisions.
Read More →
John Deere Introduces 40 P-Tier Compact Excavator
John Deere is adding a compact excavator designed for crews that need to move equipment between jobsites and handle multiple types of work with one machine. The 40 P-Tier weighs less than 10,000 pounds and offers configurable hydraulics, attachment options, and connected fleet-management capabilities.
Read More →
How Leading Fleets Improve and Why Business Plans Matter
This week, we look at what past Leading Fleet winners can teach us about making progress, plus how to build a business plan your fleet will actually use.
Read More →

