San Diego’s City Workers Win Managed Competition for Street Sweeping Services
SAN DIEGO - The City workers’ bid came in 12% lower compared with previous costs. The City's Fleet Services division currently maintains 45 street sweepers, though this number could change due to cost-cutting measures.
SAN DIEGO – The City of San Diego announced that City employees won the bid to perform street sweeping services for the City. The City workers’ bid came in 12% lower compared with previous costs. The bid will save $560,000 in annual street sweeping costs without a reduction in service, according to the City. City workers beat out three independent contractors in the bidding process.
“The winning bid includes no reduction in service levels,” said San Diego’s Mayor Jerry Sanders. “In other words, our streets will be swept with the exact same frequency at a lower cost to taxpayers. Our employees have devised a plan to work smarter and more efficiently – which is exactly what managed competition is designed to do.”
Government Fleet spoke with John Clements, fleet manager for the City of San Diego, about how street sweeping’s reduced costs will affect fleet management. According to Clements, Fleet Services’ managed competition established an annual fixed price for all vehicle and equipment maintenance. With this being the case, the number of street sweepers the City will end up using, and fleet services will end up maintaining and repairing, will vary. The City currently operates 45 sweepers.
“If a substantial number of sweepers are reduced from the fleet, management will have to determine the financial impact and reduce fleet resources (labor, parts, etc.) accordingly,” Clements said. “The street sweepers will continue to be part of the vehicle replacement program, as are all other vehicles.”
At this point it remains to be seen the specific effects this change will have on fleet services.
More Operations

New York City Orders Safety Technology for Municipal Fleet
New York City is expanding the use of pedestrian alerts and intelligent speed assistance across its non-emergency fleet. The executive order establishes new technology requirements for future vehicle purchases while accelerating retrofits on thousands of existing municipal trucks.
Read More →
The Network Behind Better Government Fleet Decisions
A discussion on why relationships across the government fleet community have played such an important role and what shapes the leadership response.
Read More →
Ford, BlackRock, Google and Carhartt Form Skilled Trades Workforce Alliance
The alliance plans to develop a stronger pipeline between training programs and available jobs while examining workforce efforts already underway across the country.
Read More →
The Network Behind Better Government Fleet Decisions
A discussion on why relationships across the government fleet community have played such an important role and what shapes the leadership response.
Read More →
What Makes Fleet Technicians Stay? | GovCast Cheat Sheet
The technician hiring and retention discussion is not new, but the way fleets respond to it continues to matter.
Read More →
On the Road with Government Fleet: Essential Podcasts for Professionals
Let's celebrate listening! Check out a GovCast podcast and discover the insights and strategies that can transform your fleet management approach.
Read More →
How Real-World Vehicle Use Guides Replacement And Budgets
Three public fleet leaders explain how they use real-world vehicle data and long-term planning to keep aging assets in service and make more informed replacement and budgeting decisions in a high-cost environment.
Read More →
When Fleet Data Has to Actually Mean Something | GovCast Cheat Sheet
Better fleet technology only works when the information behind it can actually support decisions.
Read More →
Why Public Fleet Success Depends on More Than the Vehicles | From the Show Floor with Tim Coxwell
Fleet decisions rarely stay inside the garage. From funding pressure to emissions planning, Tim Coxwell explains what it takes to keep a sheriff’s office fleet moving while planning for what comes next.
Read More →


