Court Rejects Attempt to Delay Alt-Fuel Vehicles Purchase Plan for Federal and Private Fleets
SAN FRANCISCO – Following an earlier ruling March 6 finding the U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) in violation of its obligations under the Energy Policy Act of 1992, District Court Judge William Alsup on March 30 rejected further government delay and ordered the DOE to finally come into compliance with the Act within two years, by mandating a plan for significant federal purchases of alternative fuels vehicles (AFVs).
SAN FRANCISCO – Following an earlier ruling March 6 finding the U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) in violation of its obligations under the Energy Policy Act of 1992, District Court Judge William Alsup on March 30 rejected further government delay and ordered the DOE to finally come into compliance with the Act within two years, by mandating a plan for significant federal purchases of alternative fuels vehicles (AFVs), according to the Environmental News Network. In 2002 and 2005, Judge Alsup declared the Bush administration and more than a dozen federal agencies in violation of the Act, a law designed to reduce dependence on foreign oil, lessen global warming, and cut air pollution. The Court rejected a Bush administration rulemaking that federal agencies cannot take action because petroleum-reduction goals mandated by the Act are unachievable and denied a request for an additional four years of delay. It instead ordered the DOE to revise the petroleum-reduction goal to an achievable number within one year, and then make a new determination whether the AFVs purchase rules must apply to private and municipal vehicle fleets to help achieve the goal, potentially requiring the purchase of hundreds of thousands of additional AFVs , according to the Environmental News Network report. The ruling follows an almost identical ruling in 2002, in which the DOE was ordered by Judge Alsup to develop a legal plan for compliance with the alternative-fuel vehicle-purchasing mandates, in response to lawsuit filed in 2000 by the Center for Biological Diversity and Bluewater Network. DOE was brought back into court in 2005 by these same groups after failing for a second time to comply with its obligations under the Act. In passing the Act after the first Gulf War, Congress intended to replace 30 percent of petroleum vehicle fuel use with alternative fuels by 2010, through federal purchase of less polluting vehicles, and by harnessing the purchasing power of the federal government to spur the market for natural gas, propane, ethanol, and electric vehicles, which produce less pollution and greenhouse gas emissions. The Act requires all federal agencies with light-duty fleet vehicles in major metropolitan areas to acquire at least 75 percent AFVs each year instead of traditional petroleum-fueled cars and trucks. The federal government has more than 600,000 vehicles, the largest fleet in the nation. In November 2005, settlement of the purchasing component of the lawsuit was reached with the Departments of Commerce, Labor, Transportation, and Veterans Administration, which admitted violations and agreed to increase their current AFVs acquisitions (46, 3, 29, and 24 percent, respectively) up to the required 75 percent, according to the Environmental News Network report.
More Operations

How St. Johns County Turned Fleet Data Into Better Replacement Decisions
St. Johns County, Florida, had fleet data, but turning it into reliable decision guidance was another matter. Instead of starting over with a new fleet management system, the county connected existing tools and built a scoring system that gives managers an objective look at fleet health.
Read More →
Fleet Forward Conference Introduces One-Day Passes for 2026
New one-day registration lets fleet professionals attend Tuesday, Wednesday, or Thursday, with passes available for $249.
Read More →
ENC Unveils its ZAVIR Medium-Duty Shuttle
Two variants of the concept shuttles were revealed: a low-floor configuration and a high-floor configuration.
Read More →
Could Your Next Fleet Technician Start as an Intern?
What if your next technician hasn’t worked in a fleet shop yet? What fleets are doing to free up time.
Read More →
How Phoenix Is Building Its Next Generation of Fleet Technicians
With more than 8,000 vehicles and pieces of equipment to maintain, the City of Phoenix could not afford to wait for fully trained technicians to walk through the door. Instead, they revamped their entire workforce strategy and showed how public fleets can create their own talent pipeline while preparing existing employees for increasingly complex vehicles.
Read More →
What’s Slowing Your Fleet Down?
Could a change in how work gets done help your fleet return vehicles to service sooner?
Read More →
Can Public Fleets Trust the Data Driving Their Decisions?
Public fleets have more data than ever, but inconsistent records and missing information can still undermine maintenance, replacement, and cost decisions.
Read More →
John Deere Introduces 40 P-Tier Compact Excavator
John Deere is adding a compact excavator designed for crews that need to move equipment between jobsites and handle multiple types of work with one machine. The 40 P-Tier weighs less than 10,000 pounds and offers configurable hydraulics, attachment options, and connected fleet-management capabilities.
Read More →
How Leading Fleets Improve and Why Business Plans Matter
This week, we look at what past Leading Fleet winners can teach us about making progress, plus how to build a business plan your fleet will actually use.
Read More →
Nominate a Fleet Leader for the 2027 Public Fleet Hall of Fame
Do you know a fleet leader who has made a lasting impact on the industry? Nominate this fleet professional for the 2027 Public Fleet Hall of Fame.
Read More →

