Government Fleet Logo
MenuMENU
SearchSEARCH

Limiting New Buys of SUVs, Official Says Counties Should Order More Fuel-Efficient Vehicles

SAN FRANCISCO — Noting their gas-guzzling and pollution spewing attributes, Contra Costa County Supervisor Mark DeSaulnier wants the county to limit the purchase of SUVs and instead buy as many fuel-efficient, low-emission vehicles as possible, according to the San Francisco Chronicle.

by Staff
June 29, 2004
3 min to read


SAN FRANCISCO — Noting their gas-guzzling and pollution spewing attributes, Contra Costa County Supervisor Mark DeSaulnier wants the county to limit the purchase of SUVs and instead buy as many fuel-efficient, low-emission vehicles as possible, according to the San Francisco Chronicle. "I think public agencies should be the first ones to say we're going to do something voluntarily about fuel consumption,'' DeSaulnier recently declared. “It's not that we're going to eliminate SUVs, we're just going to be more analytical about why we get them.” DeSaulnier — who drives his own BMW sedan and serves on the state Air Resources Board and the Bay Area Air Quality Management District — plans to take the idea to other local governments in the Bay Area. Not totally eliminating SUVs in the county's fleet; the policy would allow sheriff's deputies or fire officials who can show the for need an off-road vehicle to use one. A similar policy is being developed in San Diego County. State, county and city governments have long tried to save fuel costs and help the environment by purchasing cleaner vehicles. Last year, state lawmakers approved a bill by Senate President Pro Tem John Burton calling for greater fuel efficiency in the state's fleet of 73,000 vehicles and for agencies to prove they need an SUV or four-wheel drive truck before buying one. Contra Costa County has 44 SUVs — including Ford Explorers and Expeditions and Chevrolet Blazers and Tahoes — in its fleet of about 2,000 cars, which includes fire district, school and sanitation vehicles, fleet manager Frank Morgan said. Most of the SUVs are used by the sheriff or fire departments. “If you're replacing a SUV, there aren't very many questions asked,'” Morgan said. “If they're trying to purchase a new one, that's a different story.” One department wanted an SUV to pick people up at a camp, Morgan said, but “they were denied. We told them they could use a station wagon.” The county also operates 42 hybrid Toyota Priuses and six hybrid Honda Civics, as well as 59 compressed natural gas vehicles, the cleanest-burning vehicles available. Morgan called the proposed new anti-SUV policy “more glitter than glamour. Whenever a department requests a vehicle from the fleet, they have to fill out a vehicle request form which asks if they can use an alternative fuel vehicle. If they say no, they have to justify their request.” Alameda County's fleet manager, Tom Gannon, said he has 33 SUVs, mostly Dodge Durangos or Jeep Cherokees. Employees can ask for an SUV, he said, but “I usually try to talk them out of it. I try to recommend a pickup with a shell. I don't have enough money to buy a $25,000 SUV.” Santa Clara County's 2,400 vehicles include about 145 SUVs used mainly by sheriff's deputies and park rangers patrolling rugged hills, fleet manager Richard Simon said. The go-anywhere vehicles proved invaluable during floods and the Loma Prieta earthquake, he noted. However, if a county department requests a new SUV, it must be justified, he said. The county is buying more clean vehicles, including 80 hybrid cars and 100 small electric vehicles similar to golf carts. Marin and Sonoma counties also have purchased more clean-fuel vehicles. The county's assistant garage manager, Paul Makinson, said the county is testing bio-diesel fuel — made from recycled vegetable and other oils — for dump trucks. Eight gas-electric hybrid vehicles and five compressed natural gas cars are already in the motor pool. The county's fleet of nearly 800 vehicles includes fewer than 20 SUVs. Sonoma County fleet manager Dave Head said there are 15 SUVs among the 1, 200 county vehicles. The county has nine hybrid vehicles in the fleet and another 12 on order, Head said, adding that he is always looking at clean fuel options.

Topics:Operations

More Operations

a government fleet graphic showing the 2026 fleet manager of the year finalists.
OperationsApril 20, 2026

Meet the 2026 Public Sector Fleet Manager of the Year Finalists

Recognizing excellence in public fleet leadership is no small task. Learn more about this year’s three outstanding finalists, and join us at GFX in Long Beach to see who takes home the honor.

Read More →
Graphic showing Sewell Family of Companies logo and Oklahoma state seal over a background of parked vehicles, representing a statewide fleet contract agreement.
Operationsby News/Media ReleaseApril 14, 2026

Oklahoma Statewide Fleet Vehicle Contract Multi-Year Agreement to Supply Fleet Vehicles to State Agencies and Municipalities

The Sewell Family of Companies has been awarded a statewide contract to supply fleet vehicles and services to government agencies across Oklahoma through 2032.

Read More →
A collage with voting, the government fleet logo and the words cheat sheet.
OperationsApril 10, 2026

Costs, AI, EVs, and Sales in Government Fleet | GovCast Shorts

On the go and want a snapshot of our top industry news? Check out Government Fleet's new video short of what's been happening.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
A man holding a phone in a truck.
Operationsby Rachael PlantApril 10, 2026

A Practical Approach to Fleet Cost Analysis in Government Operations 

Government fleets face a distinct set of challenges that make cost analysis both more difficult and more critical.

Read More →
 a wall with the words fleet hall of fame
OperationsApril 3, 2026

Vote Now for the Public Fleet Hall of Fame

Fleet professionals can now vote for the 2026 inductees of the Public Fleet Hall of Fame. Anyone affiliated with the public fleet industry, including fleet professionals, fleet technicians, or other staff members, and suppliers, can vote.

Read More →
executive editor with images of community and networking.
OperationsApril 1, 2026

Finding Your People | The Fleet Breakroom

Why the fleet community matters, how it helps with education and support, and why asking questions can save you more trouble than you think.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
the dispatch text with images of vehicles, women in fleet, and ev charging.
OperationsMarch 30, 2026

Women in Fleet, Salary Trends, AI, and More| The March Dispatch

In this monthly lookback, we’re talking about Women’s History Month coverage, the latest Government Fleet salary data, how fleet leaders are dealing with nonstop change, and more.

Read More →
freightliner whitepaper
SponsoredMarch 26, 2026

Safety by Design: Power and Protection in the Freightliner 114SD Plus

Safety and productivity go hand-in-hand on today’s vocational jobsites. The Freightliner 114SD Plus combines advanced driver-assist technologies with proven reliability to keep crews moving constantly from start to finish. Learn how safety by design can protect your team, reduce risk, and maximize uptime.

Read More →
Isuzu commercial box truck driving in an urban area, representing a new body program with Aebi Schmidt that provides preconfigured, work-ready trucks for fleet customers.
Operationsby News/Media ReleaseMarch 24, 2026

Isuzu Launches New Premium Body Program with Aebi Schmidt called Advantic

Isuzu and Aebi Schmidt launched a new body program that offers dealers preconfigured, work-ready trucks to streamline upfitting and reduce delivery times.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
A Samsara report cover titled 'The Exoneration Factor: How Dash Cams Reduce Risk and Deliver Clear ROI for the U.S. Public Sector,' featuring a close-up photo of a dash cam mounted on a vehicle windshield with a driver reflected in the rearview mirror and a desert road visible in the background.
SponsoredMarch 24, 2026

How Dash Cams Reduce Risk and Deliver Clear ROI for the U.S. Public Sector

For government agencies, dash cams have moved from a nice-to-have to a necessity—not just for public safety, but also for operational efficiency and cost savings. Download the full report today for insights from fellow public sector leaders on how dash cams are reducing risk, lowering premiums, and delivering clear ROI.

Read More →