Debate Over County Police Cars vs. Subsidized Personal Vehicles for Law Enforcement
HILO, HAWAII — An advisory panel has found that Hawaii County would save $169,485 if police were to switch from unmarked subsidized personal vehicles to a fleet of county-owned marked patrol cars.
HILO, HAWAII — An advisory panel has found that Hawaii County would save $169,485 if police were to switch from unmarked subsidized personal vehicles to a fleet of county-owned marked patrol cars, according to the Associated Press. The county currently pays each officer up to $587 per month to drive his or her own car. Big Island police officers are currently responsible for buying their own patrol vehicle, maintaining it, and insuring it. According to the Police Fleet Implementation Working Group’s draft report, buying 293 specially equipped patrol cars would cost $111 more per car per year. However, the county would save $2,658 a year on each of the 76 non-patrol cars through fleet ownership, the report said. However, Police Chief Lawrence Mahuna does not agree with the findings and said that the panel ignored costs associated with fleet ownership, overstated how long the vehicles would last and overlooked the need for a reserve fleet, according to the Associated Press. Mahuna also said that switching to a patrol car fleet would remove an incentive to apply to the department and hurt recruitment efforts. The county owns just 37 of 376 vehicles used by the police department, and pays for liability insurance, one gallon of fuel for every 10 miles of driving on duty and a quart of motor oil for every 500 miles driven.
More Operations

How Government Fleets Are Turning Connected Vehicle Data Into Practical Decisions
Public sector fleets are using connected technology to improve visibility, but the bigger challenge is building the processes to act on the information it provides.
Read More →
RoadFlex Brings Fuel Tax Compliance and Audit-Ready Reporting to Government, Public Works Fleets
New capabilities aim to help public-sector and public works fleets streamline fuel tax exemptions, reclamation, reconciliation, and audit-ready reporting.
Read More →
2026 Public Fleet Hall of Fame Inductees Honored
This year's class includes leaders whose work has helped shape the public fleet industry.
Read More →
David Renschler Receives 2026 Legendary Lifetime Achievement Award
Andy Campbell of Sourcewell, which partnered with Government Fleet in presenting the award, recognized Renschler.
Read More →
Ross Jackson Jr. Named 2026 Public Sector Fleet Manager of the Year
His leadership, innovation, and commitment to excellence earned him one of the industry's top honors.
Read More →
Public Fleet Professionals Set to Converge as GFX Gets Underway
Known as the largest gathering of public fleet professionals in the nation, GFX will feature in-depth training sessions, emerging fleet technologies, and access to leading suppliers and service providers.
Read More →
The Technician Pipeline: Finding, Keeping, and Promoting Techs Within the Operation
A look at where to find good talent, what fleets are doing to incentivize those techs to stay within the fleet, and what promotion looks like for a technician within the public sector.
Read More →
5 Public Fleet Stories Worth Revisiting Before GFX | The May Dispatch
Public fleet leaders are being asked to prepare for more, communicate better, and make decisions that hold up under pressure.
Read More →
Drive More Profit with Greater Fleet Uptime
Fleet downtime costs money. JASPER helps keep vehicles on the road with quality remanufactured components, fast nationwide delivery, and reliable solutions that boost uptime and profitability.
Read More →Are You Tracking Your Fleet's True Total Cost of Ownership?
Bobit Business Media surveyed 190 fleet professionals and found that while most fleets are tracking costs, fragmented systems and data gaps are keeping true TCO visibility out of reach. With rising pressure to control spend in an increasingly volatile environment, the gap between what fleets think they know and what the data actually shows is wider than you might expect. See how your peers are managing costs today and where the industry still has room to improve.
Read More →


