Government Fleet Logo
MenuMENU
SearchSEARCH

Debate Over County Police Cars vs. Subsidized Personal Vehicles for Law Enforcement

HILO, HAWAII — An advisory panel has found that Hawaii County would save $169,485 if police were to switch from unmarked subsidized personal vehicles to a fleet of county-owned marked patrol cars.

by Staff
November 9, 2005
1 min to read


HILO, HAWAII — An advisory panel has found that Hawaii County would save $169,485 if police were to switch from unmarked subsidized personal vehicles to a fleet of county-owned marked patrol cars, according to the Associated Press. The county currently pays each officer up to $587 per month to drive his or her own car. Big Island police officers are currently responsible for buying their own patrol vehicle, maintaining it, and insuring it. According to the Police Fleet Implementation Working Group’s draft report, buying 293 specially equipped patrol cars would cost $111 more per car per year. However, the county would save $2,658 a year on each of the 76 non-patrol cars through fleet ownership, the report said. However, Police Chief Lawrence Mahuna does not agree with the findings and said that the panel ignored costs associated with fleet ownership, overstated how long the vehicles would last and overlooked the need for a reserve fleet, according to the Associated Press. Mahuna also said that switching to a patrol car fleet would remove an incentive to apply to the department and hurt recruitment efforts. The county owns just 37 of 376 vehicles used by the police department, and pays for liability insurance, one gallon of fuel for every 10 miles of driving on duty and a quart of motor oil for every 500 miles driven.

Topics:Operations

More Operations

A collage with voting, the government fleet logo and the words cheat sheet.
OperationsApril 10, 2026

Costs, AI, EVs, and Sales in Government Fleet | GovCast Shorts

On the go and want a snapshot of our top industry news? Check out Government Fleet's new video short of what's been happening.

Read More →
A firefighter with a phone looking at a fire truck wheel.
Operationsby Rachael PlantApril 10, 2026

A Practical Approach to Fleet Cost Analysis in Government Operations 

Government fleets face a distinct set of challenges that make cost analysis both more difficult and more critical.

Read More →
 a wall with the words fleet hall of fame
OperationsApril 3, 2026

Vote Now for the Public Fleet Hall of Fame

Fleet professionals can now vote for the 2026 inductees of the Public Fleet Hall of Fame. Anyone affiliated with the public fleet industry, including fleet professionals, fleet technicians, or other staff members, and suppliers, can vote.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
executive editor with images of community and networking.
OperationsApril 1, 2026

Finding Your People | The Fleet Breakroom

Why the fleet community matters, how it helps with education and support, and why asking questions can save you more trouble than you think.

Read More →
the dispatch text with images of vehicles, women in fleet, and ev charging.
OperationsMarch 30, 2026

Women in Fleet, Salary Trends, AI, and More| The March Dispatch

In this monthly lookback, we’re talking about Women’s History Month coverage, the latest Government Fleet salary data, how fleet leaders are dealing with nonstop change, and more.

Read More →
freightliner whitepaper
SponsoredMarch 26, 2026

Safety by Design: Power and Protection in the Freightliner 114SD Plus

Safety and productivity go hand-in-hand on today’s vocational jobsites. The Freightliner 114SD Plus combines advanced driver-assist technologies with proven reliability to keep crews moving constantly from start to finish. Learn how safety by design can protect your team, reduce risk, and maximize uptime.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Isuzu commercial box truck driving in an urban area, representing a new body program with Aebi Schmidt that provides preconfigured, work-ready trucks for fleet customers.
Operationsby News/Media ReleaseMarch 24, 2026

Isuzu Launches New Premium Body Program with Aebi Schmidt called Advantic

Isuzu and Aebi Schmidt launched a new body program that offers dealers preconfigured, work-ready trucks to streamline upfitting and reduce delivery times.

Read More →
A Samsara report cover titled 'The Exoneration Factor: How Dash Cams Reduce Risk and Deliver Clear ROI for the U.S. Public Sector,' featuring a close-up photo of a dash cam mounted on a vehicle windshield with a driver reflected in the rearview mirror and a desert road visible in the background.
SponsoredMarch 24, 2026

How Dash Cams Reduce Risk and Deliver Clear ROI for the U.S. Public Sector

For government agencies, dash cams have moved from a nice-to-have to a necessity—not just for public safety, but also for operational efficiency and cost savings. Download the full report today for insights from fellow public sector leaders on how dash cams are reducing risk, lowering premiums, and delivering clear ROI.

Read More →
paper people in pink and blue holding up signs
Operationsby Jeanny RoaMarch 23, 2026

2026 Government Fleet Salary Study: Pay Holds Strong as Workforce Pressures Mount

Government fleet managers report steady salary growth and expanding responsibilities, but an aging workforce, technician shortages, and rising technology demands are creating new long-term challenges.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
hall of fame logo with award
Operationsby Staff WriterMarch 17, 2026

Last Chance: 2026 Public Fleet Hall of Fame Nominations Close Today

Do you know a fleet leader who has made a lasting impact on the industry? Nominate this fleet professional for the 2026 Public Fleet Hall of Fame.

Read More →