Electrification has brought both excitement and contention as fleets work to navigate an evolving industry. - Photo: Government Fleet via Canva.com

Electrification has brought both excitement and contention as fleets work to navigate an evolving industry. 

Photo: Government Fleet via Canva.com

During a recent editorial roundtable (accessed here for a limited time), the conversation touched on the growth of electric vehicles in the retail market, challenges faced in fleet adoption, the uneven rollout across states, and the role of regulations in shaping the future of the fleet industry. 

Rapid Growth of EVs in Retail Market

Over the past three and a half years, EV market share has surged from 2% during the pandemic to over 9%. This substantial growth indicates a significant shift in consumer preferences towards electric vehicles.

Fleet Penetration Lagging Behind

While retail EV adoption has seen remarkable growth, fleet penetration is currently lower, hovering around 2 to 3%. The heavy-duty and vocational segments have even lower adoption rates, likely less than 1%.

Uneven Rollout Across States

The deployment of EVs in both retail and fleet sectors is uneven across states. This disparity is driven by the concentration of infrastructure and grants, with certain states, particularly on the East and West coasts, being stronger supporters of EVs.

Challenges in Fleet Adoption

Fleet adoption faces challenges, including high initial costs, leasing complexities, and fluctuating EV prices. The total cost of ownership for fleets, considering these factors, is currently uncertain. 

Infrastructure Concerns and Utility Collaboration

A primary concern in the adoption of electric vehicles is the state of infrastructure, especially the capacity of utilities to support the growing demand for electricity. Despite challenges, several utility fleets express excitement about the potential for growth. Utilities are willing to expand facilities, upgrade infrastructure, and increase electricity production to accommodate the rising number of electric vehicles on the grid.

Challenges in Heavy Truck Adoption

Heavy-duty trucks face unique challenges, including the need for significant power for fast charging. Some fleets, despite efforts, struggle to synchronize the introduction of electric trucks with the necessary charging infrastructure. This challenge is more prominent for heavy trucks that cannot afford long charging times and require substantial power.

Early Engagement for Fleet Transition

Fleets are advised to engage with all stakeholders, including construction companies and utility companies, at an early stage. Delays in electrification plans may occur due to lengthy utility planning processes, with some agencies needing up to seven years to develop a comprehensive plan for electrification. Starting early and planning for long-term goals are emphasized.

Diverse OEM Market and Caution for Buyers

The electric vehicle market is witnessing an influx of independent OEMs offering a range of electric vehicles. However, caution is advised as the market is expected to experience considerable churn, with many new entrants possibly being acquired or disappearing. Buyers are urged to be cautious in this evolving market.

Challenges in Vehicle Adoption

Despite increasing trends in vehicle adoption, challenges persist. Range limitations, payload concerns, and the struggle to maintain efficiency while loading vehicles are still hurdles. Survey results indicate that a significant percentage of respondents in the commercial trucking industry are hesitant to adopt electric vehicles, citing concerns about range, battery life, charging time, and payload capacity, a sentiment also felt by some public sector fleets. 

Driver Perception and the EV Driving Experience

Anecdotal evidence suggests that drivers, particularly in the light-duty sector, generally express positive views about electric vehicles (EVs). The driving experience itself is often not problematic, with drivers becoming fans of EVs. However, the primary challenge lies in the charging process, especially when relying on public charging infrastructure. Despite initial reservations, individuals who may not have considered EVs initially show a positive outlook, contributing to the changing landscape of consumer preferences. As EV adoption continues, considerations about the environmental impact, battery size, and the associated challenges, such as the need for increased lithium mining, become integral to the evolving conversation.

In summary, the conversation underscores the ongoing challenges in the electric vehicle transition, particularly in infrastructure development, heavy truck adoption, utility collaboration, and the cautious approach needed in an ever-changing OEM market.

About the author
Nichole Osinski

Nichole Osinski

Executive Editor

Nichole Osinski is the executive editor of Government Fleet magazine. She oversees editorial content for the magazine and the website, selects educational programming for GFX, and manages the brand's awards programs.

View Bio