Learn More: Proving the Worth of Subject Matter Experts
Pivoting to Better Auction, Spec’ing, and Data Practices
Chuck Cramer talks about the changes his fleet has made to improve how it conducts business.


Chuck Cramer
Like most fleet managers, Chuck Cramer, director of fleet services for the City of Lynchburg, Va., and his team are responsible for all assets from “cradle to grave” – from initial purchase to sale at auction.
Before COVID-19, they conducted sealed-bid auctions. They would advertise the event on Facebook, Twitter, and other social media sites. Attendees would then arrive for the event that occurs over two and a half days, review all the vehicles, and then provide their bid in a sealed envelope. This was all handled in-house. Since the pandemic, things have shifted further to the digital realm.
When the pandemic comes to a close, he says they will probably move to a hybrid of the two events.
“We serve our citizens. So, although we can make more money online, we feel an obligation to them. So, we will continue in-house auctions as we are able, but also conduct online versions so those who feel more comfortable buying from home can participate.”
He says serving the citizens is what he finds most fulfilling about his role as a fleet manger.
“It's not about making money. It's about what the citizens’ needs are and how we can best provide for them. It gives you a higher sense of purpose, seeing the bigger picture and realizing you are a part of it.”
Receiving Input for Better Spec’ing
Getting vehicle specifications just right has been a challenge; one he has worked hard to overcome.
“If you just come in blind and say, ‘here's your truck, use it,’ it's pretty easy. But when you do that, the operators and technicians say, ‘I needed this,’ or ‘why did you use this part?’ You learn fast that other team members’ input is vital to proper spec’ing.”
The first few specs he wrote, were, admittedly, less than stellar. He then sought guidance from one of his master technicians. From there, he started bringing in drivers, operators, technicians, and even the third-party parts contract company the city uses, to receive feedback.
He asked about which parts lasted longer than others, various warranties, and other information that would help him craft better vehicle specifications.
“It’s important to ask about what their experiences have been, because this assists you in making more informed decisions. They are the ones who use the equipment on a day-to-day basis, so only they truly know what they need.”
He also says within the last year or two, the fleet department realized their fleet of dump trucks had 14 different types of controls. This was a wakeup call for standardization, which will ease many processes going forward.
Training has also been added to all of the department’s bids to help improve their usage as well. This occurs in two parts in the same day: one session for operators, and another for technicians.
Getting Your Data Right
Over the past 18 months, the largest project he has been working on has been transitioning from an old fleet information system to an updated web-based version. One reason it’s taken so long is because their data was in dire need of cleanup.
“We had 20 years of data to work with. We had to decide whether we wanted to start from square one, but to get a full lifecycle out of our equipment we needed the back-data. Therefore, we decided we were going to clean up the data ourselves, and it's been both the best and worst thing we've done,” he explains.
The department got a data report at the start of the transition that said they had 2,754 pages of errors. Since Fleet’s amazing staff started the cleanup process, they’ve narrowed it down to 40 pages they couldn’t correct by themselves.
“We’re now at a place where we can sleep easy knowing we're starting with good data.”
Knowing the Right Path
As a kid, he always had a love of cars, but didn’t know enough in terms of caring for them. When he was old enough to drive, he bought a Camaro, drove it hard, and...you can guess what happened.
“I didn't have any money to fix it, so I had to do it myself. I became a self-taught mechanic and that's how I got into the technician field,” he explains.
From there, he joined the Air Force as a vehicle technician. After 25 years of service, he retired as a fleet manager. Becoming one for a government fleet became the next logical step in his career path, and provided him with an easy transition into the civilian world.
“I love what I do, and that’s why I'm still doing it.”
His advice to other fleet managers is to make sure your employees are taken care of. They need to feel included and acknowledged. Involve them in decisions when you can and when it makes sense to do so.
“Although I have much more to learn, we need to make sure people feel accepted and valued. You can feel you’re doing this properly, but if they don't personally feel they are being appreciated, you need to find out what you can do to make it apparent.”
More Operations

How Dakota County Built a More Structured Fleet Operation
Kevin Schlangen shares how Dakota County’s fleet moved from reactive repairs and limited oversight to a more structured approach built around planning, training, and long-term cost control.
Read More →
Is Your Fleet Ready Before the Storm Hits? | GovCast Cheat Sheet
Could better preparation before a storm and new vehicle technology help fleets recover faster while improving safety?
Read More →
New York City Orders Safety Technology for Municipal Fleet
New York City is expanding the use of pedestrian alerts and intelligent speed assistance across its non-emergency fleet. The executive order establishes new technology requirements for future vehicle purchases while accelerating retrofits on thousands of existing municipal trucks.
Read More →
The Network Behind Better Government Fleet Decisions
A discussion on why relationships across the government fleet community have played such an important role and what shapes the leadership response.
Read More →
Ford, BlackRock, Google and Carhartt Form Skilled Trades Workforce Alliance
The alliance plans to develop a stronger pipeline between training programs and available jobs while examining workforce efforts already underway across the country.
Read More →
The Network Behind Better Government Fleet Decisions
A discussion on why relationships across the government fleet community have played such an important role and what shapes the leadership response.
Read More →
What Makes Fleet Technicians Stay? | GovCast Cheat Sheet
The technician hiring and retention discussion is not new, but the way fleets respond to it continues to matter.
Read More →
On the Road with Government Fleet: Essential Podcasts for Professionals
Let's celebrate listening! Check out a GovCast podcast and discover the insights and strategies that can transform your fleet management approach.
Read More →
How Real-World Vehicle Use Guides Replacement And Budgets
Three public fleet leaders explain how they use real-world vehicle data and long-term planning to keep aging assets in service and make more informed replacement and budgeting decisions in a high-cost environment.
Read More →


