Related: San Diego Sets Green Fleet Targets
San Diego Launches 'Aggressive' Vehicle Replacement Initiative
The City of San Diego has begun an overhaul of its fleet management operations to reduce a backlog of aging vehicles, boost staffing, and improve an archaic software system.

Photo by Thi Dao.

Photo by Thi Dao.
The City of San Diego has begun an overhaul of its fleet management operations to reduce a backlog of aging vehicles, boost staffing, and improve an archaic software system.
Upgrading the city's aging 4,100-vehicle fleet moved to the front burner toward the end of 2015, after an analysis of the fleet unit identified the impact of aging vehicles on fleet operations. The city identified more than 700 "over-aged" vehicles (18% of the fleet) that need to be replaced with the help of consultant CST Fleet Services, according to a report presented to City Council in January.
The city's aging fleet vehicles have hurt productivity because a significant number have been in the shop. In the third quarter of 2015, 300 vehicles were in the shop. In the fourth quarter, the fleet unit reduced the number to 252 vehicles being repaired.
As a result, the city has launched a 24-month replacement plan that includes an analysis of vehicle utilization. As part of the plan, the city will swap under-utilized vehicles for over-utilized vehicles. The fleet unit plans to replace about 450 vehicles in fiscal-year 2016 and 600 vehicles in fiscal-year 2017. The city has 413 vehicles considered "critical" for replacement.
As of January, the city has ordered nearly 200 vehicles, including 76 police patrol cars, 20 refuse packers, seven fire apparatus, five wastewater drain cleaners, and two "fast response" fire rescue vehicles.
Fleet staffing has been beefed up with 27 new positions funded by the 2016 fiscal-year budget, including 20 shop positions and seven administrative positions. Three fleet repair supervisors and a program manager are expected to improve oversight of costs.
Under the prior system, the lack of direct supervisory support for administrative functions led to outdated policies and procedures. The vehicle maintenance and asset management software had been neglected, resulting in inefficient processes and unreliable data, according to the report.
"The system is several versions behind in upgrades, which contributes to obsolete reports and unreliable data, making analysis and long- and short-term planning challenging," according to a city report.
In November, the fleet unit centralized its administrative support staff at the Chollas Operations Yard, a move that "promotes cross training and consistency in operations, policies and procedures."
The initiative comes on the heels of a reorganization of the city's fleet unit toward the end of 2015, when the Fleet Services division was moved from the Public Works Department to the Internal Operations Branch under the oversight of Ron Villa, deputy chief operating officer. Alia Khouri now serves as the deputy director of the fleet unit, after moving from the city's Financial Management Department.
More Operations

Why Public Fleet Success Depends on More Than the Vehicles | From the Show Floor with Tim Coxwell
Fleet decisions rarely stay inside the garage. From funding pressure to emissions planning, Tim Coxwell explains what it takes to keep a sheriff’s office fleet moving while planning for what comes next.
Read More →
How Government Fleets Helped Build America
As the United States celebrates its 250th anniversary, this look back explores how government fleets evolved from horse-drawn wagons to specialized vehicles that keep communities running today.
Read More →
Fleet History, Long-Term Maintenance, and Fleet Needs | GovCast Cheat Sheet
Public fleet work has changed dramatically, but the core responsibility remains the same: keeping communities moving.
Read More →
Recognizing Progress, Leadership in Fleets | The June Dispatch
Catch up on the past month, whether you're interested in GFX news or Government Fleets' go-to articles for your operation.
Read More →
Beyond Utilization Rates: Smarter Fleet Replacement Decisions
Vehicle replacement decisions affect every aspect of fleet performance, from operating costs to asset availability. This guide explores how fleet leaders use integrated data, benchmarking, and lifecycle analytics to determine the right fleet size and optimize replacement timing with greater confidence.
Read More →
Talking Success, Leadership, and Fleet Needs
A perspective on the future of fleet management, the lessons learned about building strong teams in the public sector, and how to carry forward the department’s strategic direction.
Read More →
Proactive Approaches to Fleet Management Challenges with Erinn DeJonge
In this episode, we put the spotlight on the professional journey of Erinn DeJonge, CAFM, who brings a wealth of experience to her role as the fleet business operations manager at Sarasota County Government.
Read More →
The FleetGap Initiative: Transitioning from Military to Civilian Fleet Roles
FleetGap is working to build the missing bridge between service members preparing for civilian careers and fleet employers facing workforce shortages.
Read More →
How Government Fleets Are Turning Connected Vehicle Data Into Practical Decisions
Public sector fleets are using connected technology to improve visibility, but the bigger challenge is building the processes to act on the information it provides.
Read More →
RoadFlex Brings Fuel Tax Compliance and Audit-Ready Reporting to Government, Public Works Fleets
New capabilities aim to help public-sector and public works fleets streamline fuel tax exemptions, reclamation, reconciliation, and audit-ready reporting.
Read More →

