Related: Inside the Labor Rate Debate
Audit Questions N.C. Utility's Maintenance Charges to City
The Fayetteville (N.C.) Public Works Commission has been charging the city up to 44% in markup and administrative charges to service the city's vehicles, according to an internal audit.
The Fayetteville (N.C.) Public Works Commission, which provides maintenance services to all the municipal fleet vehicles, has been charging the city up to 44% in markup and administrative charges to service the city's vehicles, according to an internal audit.
The charges, which are on top of the costs for performing maintenance and repairs, cost the city $1.4 million in fiscal 2014 and $1.1 million through the first eight months of this fiscal year. The city pays $61.13 per hour for labor. Since 2011, the city has paid an average of $4.9 million annually to the PWC to repair and maintain its vehicles.
City Councilman Mitch Colvin told the Fayetteville Observer the audit was eye-opening and said the markup costs are "just astronomical" and unacceptable. A spokeswoman for the commission told the media outlet several issues identified in the audit were being addressed in a new fleet maintenance agreement.
The audit also determined that the commission uses the FASTER software system and does not provide the city documentation supporting the billed costs. The commission provides limited access to the software system.
The audit studied four fiscal years from 2011 to 2014 during which the city averaged $4.9 million for fleet expenditures. The city projects $6.1 million for fleet costs in the 2015 fiscal-year budget.
Other concerns raised by the audit focused on preventive maintenance costs, vehicle downtime, and quality of work.
More Maintenance

Reducing Long-Term Maintenance Costs and Downtime
Downtime is rarely caused by a single surprise failure but rather by an issue that builds over time through setbacks ranging from deferred maintenance to poor replacement planning. So what's the fix?
Read More →
Beyond Utilization Rates: Smarter Fleet Replacement Decisions
Vehicle replacement decisions affect every aspect of fleet performance, from operating costs to asset availability. This guide explores how fleet leaders use integrated data, benchmarking, and lifecycle analytics to determine the right fleet size and optimize replacement timing with greater confidence.
Read More →
The Future of Government Fleet Technicians with Mike Cleary
Insight on preparing for hybrid and electric vehicle service, what fleets need to know about recruiting technicians in a competitive market, and how to make the most of limited training budgets.
Read More →
Work Orders Are More Than Records. They're a Roadmap to Fleet Availability
What if your work orders could predict failures, uncover hidden costs, and boost fleet availability? Here's how leading fleets are using the data.
Read More →
Drive More Profit with Greater Fleet Uptime
Fleet downtime costs money. JASPER helps keep vehicles on the road with quality remanufactured components, fast nationwide delivery, and reliable solutions that boost uptime and profitability.
Read More →
The Fleet Efficiency Gap: Where Budgets, Utilization & Risk Collide
Departmentally assigned vehicles often create hidden costs through underutilization, poor visibility, and increased administrative burden. This whitepaper explores how shared motor pool strategies help fleets reduce costs, improve accountability, and optimize vehicle utilization.
Read More →
How Public Fleets Earn Public Trust and Operate Under Scrutiny
Taxpayers judge public services by what they can see. Learn how state and local government fleets are using data and transparency to demonstrate reliability, strengthen accountability, and build public confidence in every mile driven.
Read More →
Smart Seasonal Maintenance Tips for Government Fleets
Government fleets carry extra weight, and routes, schedules, and public trust depend on reliability. A systematic spring checklist keeps vehicles in service when agencies need them most.
Read More →
BendPak Debuts 12APF Two-Post Lift for Tall Vehicles in Low-Ceiling Shops
New 12,000-lb. open-top lift designed for commercial vans, trucks, SUVs, and fleet vehicles
Read More →
Reducing Risk and Improving Safety in Public Sector Fleets with Advanced Driver-Assist Technology
Public sector fleets face increasing pressure to improve safety, reduce liability, and operate efficiently. See how advanced vehicle technologies are helping agencies protect drivers, the public, and their budgets.
Read More →

