Michigan State Police Tests Aftermarket Tires

January 13, 2012

LANSING, MI – The Michigan State Police's Precision Driving Unit has released the results of an intensive battery of tests measuring the ability of aftermarket tires to meet the often-punishing demands of law enforcement driving.

You can download the test results here.

Troopers in the unit tested six tire brands—Cooper, Firestone, Goodyear, Nitto, Nokian, and Pirelli—on various law enforcement vehicles to rate the durability of aftermarket tires for agencies. During two weeks of testing in June, tires were studied in three major areas—braking, endurance, and steady-state turning.

In addition to the four individual tests, troopers also measured tire wear after two 50-lap runs. Tires were run counter clockwise for 50 laps and clockwise for another 50 laps. The percentage of wear for each tire was then then measured.

Tires were first tested for "straight line" stopping on dry asphalt—a benchmark test for vehicles during the unit's annual September evaluation of new models. Distance to a dead stop is measured for the vehicle (or tire, in this case) traveling at 60mph.

Next, straight-line braking tests are done on wet jennite, a calcium silicate hydrate used to seal asphalt. Stopping distance is measured from 35mph to a dead stop.

The tires are then tested on wet asphalt with the driver braking into a turn from a speed of 40mph.

The steady-state turning test is completed in two parts. Drivers accelerate while turning in a clockwise and counter clockwise circle for each test. The tires are tested with and without electronic stability control.

The Precision Driving Unit compared aftermarket tires to original equipment manufacturer tires outfitted on fleet vehicles when built on the assembly line for the purposes of testing.

The MSP tested the following tires: the Goodyear Eagle RS-A on the Dodge Charger, Ford Crown Vic (CVPI), Chevrolet Caprice, Chevrolet Impala, and Chevrolet Tahoe; the Firestone Firehawk GT Pursuit on the Charger, Ford CVPI, and Tahoe; the Cooper CS4 on the Ford CVPI, Impala, and Charger; the Nokian WR G2 on the Caprice and Impala; the Nitto NT 850 Plus on the Caprice, Impala, and Ford CVPI; and the Pirelli Pzero Nero on the Ford CVPI; and P6 tire on the Impala.

Tire evaluators purchased the tires from a retail store to ensure each tire was an actual production version. Goodyear, Firestone, Pirelli and Nitto categorized their test entries as "High Performance All Season," whereas Nokian labels its model as an "All Weather Plus" tire, and Cooper calls its tire a "Premium Luxury Touring" tire.

In the first set of braking tests of the Goodyear, Nitto, and Nokian tires on the Caprice, the Nitto tire performed best in wet and dry conditions. In the braking and turning test, the Nokian tire performed best.

In the test of the Cooper, Firestone, and Goodyear tires on the Charger, the Cooper tire performed best new in all three tests, but was too worn to be tested in the "worn" tests. The Goodyear and Firestone tires performed different in the dry vs. wet braking tests, with the Goodyear tire coming in first during the dry test and the Firestone coming in first in the wet, braking test. When braking during a turn for the worn tires, Goodyear came in first.

In the tests of the Goodyear and Firestone tests on the Tahoe, the new version of the Firestone tire performed better in three out of the four tests, but was too worn to be tested against the Goodyear tire in the "worn" tests.

For the Pirelli, Cooper, Goodyear, and Nokian tires tested on the Impala, the new version of the Cooper tire again had the best performance in four tests but was so worn it couldn't be tested against the other three in the "worn" tests.

On the Ford CVPI, where MSP tested the Goodyear, Cooper, Firestone, Nokian, and Nitto tires, again the new version of the Cooper tire performed best in two of the four tests but came in fourth in the braking-during-a-turn test, and third in the lateral acceleration test. The Cooper tire was too worn for testing in the "worn" tests, and the Nitto tire performed best in three of the four "worn" tire tests.

Replacement tire prices increased 4-13% in 2011 due to higher commodity costs used to manufacture tires, such as oil, rubber and steel, according to Automotive Fleet's 20th annual operating costs survey.

You can see a video where the Michigan State Police describe the testing methodology here.

By Greg Basich and Paul Clinton

Comments

  1. 1. Al Thompson, R.E.A. C,E.I [ April 23, 2012 @ 09:00PM ]

    Glad to see the State of Michigan is looking at aftermarket alternatives that may be as good or close to OEM equipment to save money without losing quality. I wish more municipalities would look at selected aftermarket equipment and devices objectively to reduce costs w/o reducing quality.

 

Comment On This Story

Name:  
Email:  
Comment: (Maximum 10000 characters)  
Leave this field empty:
* Please note that every comment is moderated.

FleetFAQ

Fleet Management And Leasing

Jack Firriolo from Merchants will answer your questions and challenges

View All

 

Public Fleet Tracking And Telematics

Amin Amini from Verizon will answer your questions and challenges

View All

 

Fuel Management

Bernie Kanavagh from WEX will answer your questions and challenges

View All

 

Recent Topics

I am requesting feedback on how often you replace street sweepers? Also, when you surplus the old sweeper, what has brought you the...

View Topic

How many different types of antifreeze do you stock? I’m curious to know what others are doing to deal with the numerous specifications...

View Topic

Fleet Documents

1114 Fleet Documents (and counting) to Download!

Sponsored by

Adding non-original equipment to a vehicle to change its operational capabilities.

Read more

Blog

Managing a Police Fleet

How Chevrolet's Tahoe PPV Differs From its Retail Relative

By Michaela Kwoka-Coleman
For the Chevrolet Tahoe PPV, tires are added to the vehicles that are capable of handling speeds of up to 134 mph and the brakes are adjusted to handle frequent stopping at high speeds.

Police Vehicles Pushed to the Limit in California

By Paul Clinton